Termination of employment can be a difficult and often stressful experience, whether you’re an employer managing workplace conduct or an employee facing unexpected job loss. In Canada, one of the most serious and immediate forms of termination is known as just cause termination. This form of dismissal occurs when an employer ends an employee’s contract without providing notice or severance due to serious misconduct or a fundamental breach of the employment relationship.
Understanding what just cause termination entails, the conditions under which it is applied, and its legal implications is essential for both employers and employees. In this blog, we explore the meaning of just cause termination, examples of just cause, the legal standards involved, and the steps one should take when facing or initiating such a dismissal.
What Does “Just Cause” Mean?
In the context of employment law, “just cause” refers to a legal justification for terminating an employee without notice or severance. It must be based on serious misconduct, such as dishonesty, insubordination, or habitual neglect of duty. Unlike a typical termination without cause, where the employee is given notice or paid compensation in lieu of notice, just cause termination severs the employment relationship immediately and without further obligations from the employer.
However, because this type of termination has significant consequences for the employee, courts and tribunals apply a high standard when determining whether just cause existed. The burden of proof is always on the employer.
Common Grounds for Just Cause Termination
Just cause termination is not taken lightly. Employers must have strong evidence and justification to terminate someone under this category. Here are several examples that could potentially warrant just cause:
1. Dishonesty or Fraud
Acts such as theft, embezzlement, falsifying documents, or lying about qualifications are typically considered serious misconduct. Even one incident of dishonesty can be sufficient for just cause, depending on the context and impact on trust.
2. Insubordination
If an employee willfully disobeys a lawful and reasonable order, especially after being warned or counseled, it may be considered insubordination. This reflects a refusal to acknowledge the authority of the employer.
3. Workplace Harassment or Violence
Any form of workplace harassment, discrimination, physical altercation, or threats against co-workers or supervisors may justify immediate dismissal.
4. Chronic Absenteeism or Tardiness
Repeated failure to show up to work on time or at all, particularly without explanation, could be grounds for just cause. However, the employer must demonstrate that warnings were issued and expectations were clearly set.
5. Poor Performance
While poor performance alone does not usually justify just cause, it can lead to termination if combined with ongoing neglect of duty and failure to improve after feedback and support.
6. Substance Abuse at Work
Being intoxicated or impaired on the job, especially in roles involving safety or trust, can be serious enough to justify immediate dismissal.
7. Breach of Confidentiality
Sharing confidential company or client information without authorization can be a breach of trust that justifies termination.
8. Conflict of Interest or Moonlighting
Engaging in outside work that competes with the employer’s business or creates a conflict of interest may also be sufficient for just cause dismissal.
ALSO READ: What to Expect During the Divorce Process with a Lawyer
The Legal Standard for Just Cause Termination
Canadian courts have consistently emphasized that just cause is the capital punishment of employment law—a phrase that underscores the severity and finality of this type of dismissal.
Because of its impact on the employee’s reputation, future employment, and financial security, courts require:
- Clear evidence of misconduct
- Proportionality of the punishment to the wrongdoing
- Progressive discipline when appropriate (i.e., warnings, performance improvement plans)
- Contextual consideration, such as the employee’s length of service, position, history, and the workplace culture
Employers must also follow procedural fairness and cannot rely on mere suspicion or unproven allegations.
Difference Between Just Cause and Without Cause Termination
Many people confuse just cause with termination without cause, but the two are very different:
| Just Cause Termination | Termination Without Cause |
| No notice or severance required | Employer must give notice or severance |
| Based on serious misconduct | Based on business reasons, restructuring, or no specific reason |
| Requires high standard of proof | No misconduct needs to be shown |
| May damage employee’s reputation | Less stigma and often eligible for EI benefits |
Legal Implications for Employers
Employers who wrongfully claim just cause when terminating an employee may face legal consequences. If the court finds that the termination was not truly for just cause, the employer may be liable for:
- Payment of reasonable notice or pay in lieu
- Additional damages for bad faith or mental distress
- Costs associated with legal proceedings
This makes it critical for employers to consult legal counsel before taking action. Careful documentation, internal investigations, and progressive discipline are often required to establish just cause.
Legal Implications for Employees
Employees terminated for just cause lose out on several key entitlements:
- No severance pay or termination notice
- May not qualify for Employment Insurance (EI) benefits
- Potential harm to reputation and employability
If an employee believes they were wrongfully dismissed, they can file a complaint with a provincial labor board or pursue a civil claim for wrongful dismissal.
In such cases, seeking a just cause dismissal lawyer consultation can help employees understand their rights, assess the strength of their case, and explore options for compensation or reinstatement.
Mitigating the Risk of Just Cause Dismissal
For employees, preventing a just cause dismissal starts with understanding workplace policies, fulfilling job duties, and maintaining professional conduct. Some helpful tips include:
- Following company procedures and protocols
- Documenting communications with supervisors
- Requesting support or clarification when needed
- Acknowledging and correcting mistakes promptly
- Engaging with performance improvement plans seriously
Employers, on the other hand, can protect themselves by maintaining clear policies, providing training, documenting issues, and using fair and transparent discipline processes.
Final Thoughts
Just cause termination is one of the most serious actions an employer can take against an employee. While it is sometimes justified by severe misconduct, it must be approached with caution, supported by solid evidence, and evaluated through a legal lens. For employees, being accused of just cause termination can be devastating, but legal recourse is often available if the dismissal was unfair or improperly handled.
Whether you’re an employer considering this form of termination or an employee facing dismissal, understanding your rights and responsibilities is crucial. When in doubt, legal guidance is your best tool in navigating this high-stakes area of employment law.
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Skilled Assistance for Quick Case Resolution
